Should Christians Advocate for Open Borders?
Talking Points:
- Throughout scripture, well maintained walls around cities are looked at as a positive, not negative, situation. One of the very first tasks of Nehemiah was to rebuild the wall around Jerusalem and it was celebrated when it was completed. Proverbs 25:28, Nehemiah 2:11-18
- The building of walls did not eliminate God’s commands to care for the foreigners residing in Israel. Leviticus 19:34
- Foreigners were expected to obey the commands God had given the Israelites. In modern application, governments have the right to expect obedience to laws and regulations unless they contradict God’s laws. This would include immigration laws. Numbers 9:14
Discussion:
- Proverbs 25:28 compares the lack of self control to a city with broken walls. What were the dangers of a city with broken walls?
- Do you support open borders for the U.S.? How would you defend your answer biblically?
- Has your perspective on immigration been shaped most by your upbringing, political affiliation, or the Bible? Why do you think this topic can be so divisive, even among Christians?
- Numbers 9:14 required foreigners residing in Israel to celebrate the Passover. What modern applications can we make from that principle?
- How does knowing that our primary citizenship is in heaven affect the way we treat immigrants in our country, whether they are here legally or illegally?
Is Amnesty the Answer?
Talking Points:
- Governments have a responsibility to protect their citizens and ensure law and order.
- The Bible has multiple passages that call for the equal application of justice. We are not to give preferential treatment to the rich or to the poor. Proverbs 24:24-25, Leviticus 19:15
- Although the government has a responsibility to elevate the needs of its citizens, Christians are called to love our neighbors as ourselves. Our neighbors are anyone we come into contact with, as evidenced by the parable of the good Samaritan.
Discussion:
- How does the biblical principle of justice apply to the amnesty debate for illegal immigrants?
- Do we find examples in the Bible of situations where rules were broken and the person wasn’t condemned? What are some of the underlying factors in those stories? Should we take that into consideration when looking at immigration laws?
- What are practical ways we can love our neighbor as ourselves?
- How did Jesus define who our neighbor is in the parable of the good Samaritan? Does that expand your view of who your neighbor is?
- Is the argument, “you’re breaking up a family” a valid reason to be against deportation? Why or why not?
How Do We Obey the Command To Love Our Neighbors as Ourselves?
Talking Points:
- A biblical argument can be made that a government should prioritize care and protection for its own citizens over those from other countries. There is biblical precedent for Christians to prioritize care for those in the church. 1 John 4:11-12, , 1 Peter 4:9
- As believers, Jesus commands us to love our neighbors. In the parable of the Good Samaritan, our neighbor is defined as all those we come to whom we come in contact. A person’s immigration status shouldn’t affect the compassion we have for them. Luke 10:27
- If we really want to be compassionate, we should consider how we meet the need at the source. Even if we quadrupled the number of immigrants we received in the U.S., it wouldn’t make a dent in the three billion people worldwide who earn less than $2 per day. James 1:27, Hebrews 13:2-3
Discussion:
- Would you agree or disagree with the following statement: We have plenty of people in our country who need help before we should worry about those in other countries? How do you support your answer biblically?
- Have you ever served a mission trip to another country? If not, would you consider it? If you have, what lessons did you learn?
- What are practical steps you can take to show compassion to those in your community?
- Have you ever prayed about sponsoring a child overseas? If not, would you consider it now?
- Why do you think Jesus chose a Samaritan when he was asked, “Who is my neighbor?”