Click for Shownotes

We all have that friend who wants to dominate our time or the friend who never initiates plans. It’s frustrating if you don’t have the right expectations and boundaries in place. 

Today we’re going to describe 4 common dynamics that happen in friendships and how a lack of proper boundaries can lead to hurt and frustration.

Compliant – Compliant “Whatever you want

We’ve discussed the compliant personality in other episodes. Two compliant friends likely leads to inauthentic friendship. Here’s why. Neither person is honest about their true feelings for fear of hurting the other person. So both say “yes” to plans they don’t want to do. Both end up feeling resentful of the other because they’re doing things they don’t want to do.

How do you draw a boundary in this dynamic? Speak up. Be honest when you said yes but meant no. Invite your friend to be honest, too. Make a commitment to not commit to a request for 24 hrs and make sure you really want to do something. If you decide you don’t, say no.

Compliant – Controlling (Aggressive) “My way or the highway”

This dynamic is the most obvious. You have the compliant just trying to keep the peace and the aggressive dominating and controlling. Even though the compliant is allowing the dynamic, they internally resent it. 

How do you draw a boundary? Compliant likely needs to be the one to say “enough”. The aggressive is probably clueless because they’ve grown accustomed to getting their way in every relationship. Be clear about how you feel and why it frustrates and say you won’t give into aggressives every wish moving forward. It’s a new negotiation for a different kind of friendship. The compliant needs to take responsibility for their resentment and draw the boundary. The aggressive needs to respect the boundary. 

Compliant – Controlling (Manipulative) “Help! I need you”

The manipulative controller is less obvious than the aggressive but the result is the same-it’s always their way. In this dynamic, the compliant is always rescuing or on call for the manipulative friend. The manipulator doesn’t plan ahead so they often find themselves in a bind due to their lack of planning. The compliant grows tired of being used so they create distance. 

How do you draw the boundary? Compliant needs to address it. Clearly stating how they feel used by the manipulator and that they aren’t going to be the rescuer every time. Express a desire for a give and take relationship where both serve and help the other. 

Compliant – non-responsive “I always initiate”

Compliant feels like they do all the work in the friendship. They reach out to make plans or to check in. The non-responsive never does that. Compliant feels unimportant. Non-responsive may feel overwhelmed by the compliants need for attention.

How do you draw a boundary? Both speak up. Compliant can be honest that they feel undervalued when the other never reaches out or initiates. Non-responsive may need to be honest about their ability to be the kind of friend the other needs. If expectations can’t match, stop forcing the friendship and maybe move on.

Talking Points:
  • Compliant-Compliant: You are both afraid to express true desires or to be honest about your preferences-so neither of you get what you want. Learn to speak up.
  • Compliant-Aggressive Controller: You are always saying yes to keep the peace while the other person steam rolls- so you get bitter and angry. Learn to say no and stand your ground.
  • Compliant-Manipulative Controller: You are always saying yes while the other person takes advantage of you-so you grow bitter and tired. Learn to confront passive aggressive behavior.
  • Compliant-Non-responsive: You’re looking for connection but you’re ignored or rebuffed- so you feel rejected. Learn to take a hint and back off.
Discussion:
  1. Read the talking points above as a group, including scripture references. What are your initial thoughts about these points or about the podcast lesson (see audio above)?
  2. Describe a friendship that has been challenging for you. Which of the 4 dynamics best describes that friendship?
  3. What are the potential problems in a friendship with two compliant friends? Why is it important to be able to express your real desires?
  4. Describe a controlling friend in your life. How does that friendship affect you?
  5. Read Ephesians 4:25. Have you ever felt taken advantage of by a friend? Explain. Why is it better to be honest about your frustrations compared to just taking it or completely walking away?
  6. Have you ever been non-responsive to someone in your life? Why? Has someone been unresponsive towards you? What insights can you glean from that?
  7. Read Proverbs 18:24 and 1 Corinthians 15:33. Would you categorize a friend as bad company for you? Explain. What adjustments might you need to make with this person?

See Also:

View the FlexTalk version of this topic.
Adapted from Boundaries by Henry Cloud and John Townsend.