Let’s think carefully as Christians about three different lenses through which to view transgenderism and gender dysphoria.
Talking Points:
- The Integrity Approach looks at gender through Genesis 1-2. God made people as male or female, so gender is fixed. Transgenderism is viewed as a violation of that original design. This approach can be judgmental and may permit Christians to “write off” people who struggle with this issue.
- The Disability Approach looks at gender through Genesis 3. Sin has entered into God’s perfect creation, so the original design is broken. There are many human conditions that are out of step with the original created order, which causes distress. This approach is more compassionate but is prone to minimizing biblical principles.
- The Diversity Approach argues that transgender persons should be celebrated and honored as a positive part of human diversity. There is no single norm for gender identity, and transgendered persons should be affirmed and welcomed. This is the approach our culture has taken but it doesn’t reflect the biblical perspective on gender.
Discussion:
- Initial reactions to this topic? What jumped out at you?
- How would you define gender identity and gender dysphoria?
- How is gender identity different from sexual orientation?
- Read Genesis 1:27 and Genesis 2:21-24. Describe the Integrity Approach to transgenderism in your own words. What do you see as the strengths and weaknesses of the Integrity Approach?
- Read Genesis 3:6-7. Describe the Disability Approach in your own words. What do you see as the strengths and weaknesses of the Disability Approach?
- Describe the Diversity Approach in your own words. What do you see as the strengths and weaknesses of the Diversity Approach?
- What is the number one question you would have for a transgender person? How can you show more compassion for those who struggle with this issue while not condoning or agreeing with it?
- Is there a step you need to take based on today’s topic?
